Which piece would you hear again? Three models received the same challenge: write an original piano piece people would choose to hear again, with a memorable theme, development and a deliberate ending. Each first complete score was frozen before playback. Here are their longer pieces together, Terra, Astra and Opus, in that order. The earlier short duel is not included.

The film gives every piece its complete notes and ending. A shared piano and warm falling-note graphics follow the original timing, with brief title cards and no narration over the music.

Listen to the combined film

The 5:45 film passed technical timing, audio-signal and normal-speed player checks. These checks do not judge musical quality; independent human listening and physical-phone acceptance have not been recorded.

piano-three-composers-web.mp4
Terra → Astra → Opus · three frozen long scores · shared replacement piano · 5:45

Read the transcript or media description

If playback or seeking stalls, load the full film once for timeline seeking, or download the MP4 (22 MB).

Media description: Three original solo-piano compositions, no speech. An opening shows the three independently designed covers; each chapter then identifies its model and piece. A full keyboard, warm falling bars and glowing key strikes follow the frozen note schedules. Each complete 108-second score keeps its three-second source decay before the next card. The closing asks which piece you would hear again. These are score-driven graphics, not footage of a human performance.

The poster is a separate editorial illustration made with the native image-generation tool; the film retains each model’s independently designed cover.

ChapterCompositionFirst musical note
00:00Terra — The Lantern Keeps Its Place00:04
01:55Astra — Lanterns After Rain01:57
03:48Opus — Lamplighter03:50

Terra returns to a steady lyrical phrase. Astra develops a theme from D minor toward D major. Opus carries a descending four-note idea from E minor to an E-major ending. These descriptions come from the retained scores; they are not listening verdicts.

Shared presentation, clear limits

All three use GeneralUser GS 2.0.3 and FluidSynth 2.4.4, with the same Grand Piano preset, fixed velocity and common gain. Their frozen pitches, onsets and releases are unchanged. The original browser takes and separate portrait edits remain preserved. No OnlinePianist audio or reference-video sound appears in this film.

The configured participants were gpt-6.1-terra High, gpt-6-astra High and claude-opus-5-5 High. Those identities come from retained task/session metadata, not independent provider attestation.

Matched instructions do not establish equal computation: the model products and tool interfaces differed, and comparable token/runtime budgets are unavailable. Note counts and signal measurements cannot decide which theme you remember. Which piece would you hear again?

Read the detailed method and first-attempt notes, including the original recordings, repairs and independent cover designs. The sanitized evidence separates those records from this combined edit. Download the musical brief and note schedules for Terra, Astra and Opus.

GeneralUser GS is by S. Christian Collins. Its official licence permits commercial recordings, while the author discloses uncertain provenance for some inherited samples. Retain that caveat, the author repository and licence text; this is not a legal guarantee. Original website audio/UI recordings remain private while their publication rights are unresolved.