{
  "recordedDates": {
    "round1": "2026-11-01",
    "round2": "2026-11-02"
  },
  "studyLimit": "Three particular configured agent/product setups, with different contexts/harness conditions; no equal-compute or universal ranking claim.",
  "round1": {
    "durationLimitSeconds": 30,
    "heldKeyLimit": 3,
    "astra": {
      "declaredSeconds": 24,
      "notes": 53,
      "identity": "gpt-6-astra/high local configuration; independent attestation unavailable",
      "technicalRepairs": 1,
      "reason": "Half sustain in original take; identical score replayed with sustain off"
    },
    "opus": {
      "declaredSeconds": 24,
      "notes": 56,
      "identity": "claude-opus-5-5 session metadata; effort unknown; independently unattested",
      "technicalRepairs": 0,
      "setupStopsBeforeNotes": 2,
      "sessionIsolation": "not fresh; protocol read, no Astra music inspected"
    },
    "judgeResponses": {
      "Gemini4Argon": {
        "Opus": 4,
        "Astra": 0
      },
      "Qwen3.8OmniFlash": {
        "Astra": 3,
        "Opus": 1
      }
    },
    "judgeLimit": "Four order-alternated model responses each; not eight independent humans or audience votes."
  },
  "round2": {
    "astra": {
      "modelConfig": "gpt-6-astra/high via task control",
      "providerRevisionAttestation": "unavailable",
      "firstCompositionAttempts": 1,
      "websiteTakes": 1,
      "captureRepairs": 0,
      "sourceScoreSha256": "0351b5bf651cf7fffa8b99c7fb3f7c54d41e90e6a8b8378b311e14bbd9082112",
      "sanitizedExportSha256": "ff4c7f3d43802e4283ead4ae3b1d64c5f780e7b104a602c94f9018792288503e",
      "notes": 314,
      "musicSeconds": 108,
      "newRenditionSeconds": 117.5,
      "audioSourceCorrelationMinimum": 0.999959780188616,
      "encodedVisualErrorMaxMs": 25.000000000005684,
      "normalSpeedPlaybackPassed": true,
      "droppedFrames": 0,
      "retainedFailedEditVariants": 4,
      "editFailureLimit": "Video timing/padding export corrections; not extra compositions, musical takes or capture repairs."
    },
    "opus": {
      "modelConfig": "claude-opus-5-5/high via Claude Code v2.1.316, Claude Pro credits off",
      "providerRevisionAttestation": "unavailable",
      "firstCompositionAttempts": 1,
      "websiteTakes": 1,
      "captureRepairs": 0,
      "sourceScoreSha256": "587eaaae9d7111a42604b9541fa1ced84847862f50e988f9333215bde04e353c",
      "sanitizedExportSha256": "126544bea45d92d176dfddb9a85a15b2d4addb8dc6ce4aea7519b8c54e5e7ce9",
      "notes": 341,
      "musicSeconds": 108,
      "newRenditionSeconds": 117.5,
      "audioSourceCorrelationMinimum": 0.9999609828593281,
      "encodedVisualErrorMaxMs": 29.43333333332987,
      "normalSpeedPlaybackPassed": true,
      "droppedFrames": 0
    },
    "terra": {
      "modelConfig": "gpt-6.1-terra/high via parent task control, fresh Codex task with no inherited turns",
      "providerRevisionAttestation": "unavailable",
      "ordinaryUsageAndOverflowSettings": "not independently attested; no paidAPI or model fallback reported",
      "firstCompleteCompositionAttempts": 1,
      "intermediateGeneratorValidationFailuresBeforeFirstCompleteScore": 2,
      "websiteTakes": 1,
      "captureRepairs": 0,
      "preflight": "sandbox Chrome launch failed; unchanged script passed through approved host execution before composition",
      "sourceScoreSha256": "46761a2961986ab09a105e206abd274fcefc775fd04752a3f84f32bfe2ea355c",
      "sanitizedExportSha256": "1a9392e1ede7276bb95a3fb7a9c772f7c4fac362a97b2fd8d405b84135c39c7c",
      "notes": 197,
      "heldKeysMaximum": 3,
      "musicSeconds": 108,
      "originalObservedActionSpanSeconds": 108.014,
      "recordedConceptToFreezeUtc": "2026-11-02T16:03:00Z/2026-11-02T16:03:47Z",
      "timingLimit": "Logged creative interval, not end-to-end latency or equalcompute proof.",
      "thumbnailFirstSvgSha256": "7b21fb43be0f24a30dd03cbb7b9b46b505ee7d2fcf1721d16870a1a701a678a7",
      "thumbnailRepairs": 0,
      "newRenditionSeconds": 117.5,
      "audioSourceCorrelationMinimum": 0.9999632258007679,
      "encodedVisualErrorMaxMs": 16.66666666666572,
      "normalSpeedPlaybackPassed": true,
      "droppedFrames": 0
    }
  },
  "replacement": {
    "engine": "FluidSynth2.4.4",
    "soundfont": "GeneralUserGS2.0.3",
    "officialRepository": "https://github.com/mrbumpy409/GeneralUser-GS",
    "assetSha256": "9575028c7a1f589f5770fccc8cff2734566af40cd26ed836944e9a5152688cfe",
    "bank": 0,
    "programZeroBased": 0,
    "preset": "Grand Piano",
    "sampleRate": 48000,
    "velocity": 100,
    "synthGain": 0.2,
    "commonEditGainDb": 12,
    "reverb": false,
    "chorus": false,
    "pieceSpecificNormalization": false,
    "websiteAssetsReused": false,
    "licenceCaveat": "Author discloses uncertain provenance for some inherited samples; no legal guarantee."
  },
  "humanListening": "Pending for Round2 and replacement drafts.",
  "costLimit": "Astra/Opus admission records retain observed subscription safeguards and no new API/overflow spend. Terra reports no paidAPI/model fallback, but ordinary/overflow settings were not independently attested; no billing guarantee inferred. Replacement rendering made no provider model calls. Full subscription/machine costs and equal token/compute budgets are not measured.",
  "imageryObservation": {
    "sameLockedBriefCore": true,
    "lanternLampLightRainImageryPrescribed": false,
    "limit": "Similar titles/imagery are an observation under one shared task, not proof of independent originality or a general model-creativity rule."
  },
  "combinedPresentation": {
    "status": "published article/first-party film candidate; YouTube not uploaded",
    "order": [
      "terra",
      "astra",
      "opus"
    ],
    "durationSeconds": 345,
    "frames": 10350,
    "musicFirstOnsetsGlobalSeconds": [
      4,
      117,
      230
    ],
    "sourceAudioSecondsEach": 111,
    "fullSourceDecaysSecondsEach": 3,
    "instrumentAndGainShared": true,
    "notesChanged": false,
    "visualTreatment": "original warm Canvas2D falling notes, glow and particles, landscape16:9",
    "outputs": [
      {
        "file": "piano-three-composers-master.mp4",
        "bytes": 47328737,
        "sha256": "7fba2f1270c5197494ab062c0dc15c3b0b134c099c8ce2f61e20f4b29a93d86a",
        "fullDecode": true,
        "everyPerformanceFrameKeyStatePassed": true,
        "sourceAudioCheckpointsPassed": true,
        "audioPeakDbfs": -8.98620884178037
      },
      {
        "file": "piano-three-composers-web.mp4",
        "bytes": 21831700,
        "sha256": "d1a6dc1addf8d9ec74d8226616b261f75dffc1175987d5cb2853a4c778191851",
        "fullDecode": true,
        "everyPerformanceFrameKeyStatePassed": true,
        "sourceAudioCheckpointsPassed": true,
        "audioPeakDbfs": -9.07693370702685
      }
    ],
    "normalSpeedMutedPlaybackPassed": true,
    "humanListening": "not independently recorded",
    "physicalPhoneReview": "not recorded",
    "newCompositionAttempts": 0,
    "publicationAuthorized": true
  }
}
