# Candidate A — independent first-attempt acceptance review **Outcome: not accepted; not ready under the frozen brief.** The unchanged source has material viewport clipping and contrast failures. This is an assessment of one submission in the supplied Chromium captures, not a universal ranking. No repair, browser run, or source edit was performed for this review. Browser results identify Chromium 156.0.8078.79, report no page errors or network attempts, and tie captures to the unchanged artifact. Source references are in `source-review-independent.md`; captures and machine observations are in `browser/`. | Gate | Judgment | Evidence and scope | |---|---|---| | C01 standalone complete HTML | Pass | Source begins with doctype and ends with closing HTML, with inline CSS/JS and local SVG references; source inspection found no external resource dependencies. Browser reports empty network and error arrays. | | C02 identity and honest copy | Pass | Source contains all required identity and exact disclaimer, with no prohibited claims identified. | | C03 ten distinguishable components | Fail | The 1440×900 p50 capture clips the rotor and omits the caseback below the viewport; 844×390 p50 clips the lower stack from case middle downward. At 320×568 p50 the seconds-hand label clips at the right edge: its measured right edge is 327.34px in a 320px viewport. The case-middle label ends at 318.98px, so the prior claim that it was clipped was incorrect. A separate guide exists, but the parts must remain identifiable in the exploded view. | | C04 hand geometry | Pass | Source rotations 305.25°, 63°, 180° share origin and assembly base, and tip radii 126, 169, 176 give required relative lengths and seconds reach. Captured assembled dial visually corresponds to 10:10:30. | | C05 conceptual anatomy | Pass | Source and the combined 320×568 and desktop midpoint captures show a translucent crystal, open bezel and case ring, coaxial front-to-back arrangement, toothed movement and partial rotor distinct from caseback. This assesses conceptual illustration only, not mechanical simulation or engineering accuracy. The viewport clipping independently fails C03/C08. | | C06 reversible progress and holds | Pass | Browser observations report 0/50/100 progress, midpoint differing, matching assembled/reassembled transforms and successful reverse 0.5 and 0 at each tested viewport. Follow-up observations also verify the three holds, ordinary wheel advancement, and Explore navigation; source defines symmetric reverse interpolation. This does not cure the clipped content. | | C07 controls and progress | Fail | The 1440×900 and 844×390 normal-motion captures hide all state controls and progress below the viewport, despite keyboard tests finding and activating controls. Their visible presence throughout the showcase is required. | | C08 responsive states and resize | Fail | Desktop p0/p100 crop the lower bracelet and hide controls; desktop p50 crops the bottom components. Landscape p50 crops much of the stack and controls. The 320×568 p50 clips text at right. Machine no-horizontal-scroll and parts-within-scene checks do not establish visibility within the viewport. | | C09 reduced motion | Fail | Browser observations report static selection survives wheel/resize and keyboard selection works; the follow-up also verifies a live preference change snapping to the static midpoint and survival through wheel and width resize, but the supplied 1440×900 reduced p50 capture clips the top of the crystal and story, so the required complete static view is not available in that captured state. Source does disable smooth behavior and continuous scroll scrubbing in reduced mode. | | C10 semantics, focus, equivalents, contrast | Fail | Semantic landmarks, named controls, descriptive SVG text and visible focus exist in source, and the 320px focus capture shows an outline. Axe reports normal-text contrast failures: hero bottom 4.08:1 and guide keys 3.41:1 against the required 4.5:1. Axe has one incomplete/unknown result per tested size; those are not passes. | **Craft, separately from acceptance:** The hero has a confident editorial hierarchy, coherent blue/silver palette and convincing dimensional detailing in the dial, bezel, crown and bracelet. The midpoint shows a thoughtfully drawn assembly with a clear axis and recognizable movement. The oversized desktop scene and the tiny, clipped phone seconds-hand label undermine the explanation; the desktop normal-motion crop especially hides the visual conclusion and controls. Motion smoothness and cinematic quality cannot be judged from still frames and machine geometry alone. **Limits:** Evidence is Chromium emulation, not physical-device or other-engine testing. Axe incomplete results need manual investigation; an automated scan does not certify accessibility. Unknown physical device and cross-engine behavior remains unassessed. No external attempts were reported in this browser run, and source inspection found no network mechanisms. First-attempt status cannot be changed by a later repair.