# Candidate B — independent first-attempt review **Outcome: not accepted.** The unaltered submission has observed required failures at C08 and C10. This finding is independent of its visual craft; there is no combined score. Evidence is limited to source review and the supplied Chromium captures and observations, not cross-browser or full accessibility certification. Captured artifact SHA-256: `83bef3ee10b5bbd27655236fe8df6fc02e56eb344a92f99d2058e6d3c6b59d9c`. ## Five dimensions - **Functional acceptance — fail.** The standalone page, copy, navigation, scroll states and keyboard controls are supported by source and browser evidence, but all required gates must pass and C08 and C10 fail. - **Visual craftsmanship — pass, within captured views.** The large editorial serif and restrained navy, brushed silver and warm-metal palette create a cohesive launch page. The assembled watch has a convincingly detailed dial and case, and the desktop midpoint clearly separates translucent crystal, rings, hands and mechanical layers. At 320px the exploded watch and mechanism details are small; in reduced-motion landscape the lower assembly is clipped. This is an assessment of the captured design, not a ranking or engineering claim. - **Reference/anatomy fidelity — pass, illustrative scope.** Source geometry and desktop midpoint show all ten keyed parts, open rings, transparent crystal, a partial weighted rotor, and an illustrated movement with bridges, wheels, screws and a balance. The source specifies the requested angles and common pivot, and the assembled image reads as a watch. The illustration is not an engineering verification. - **Accessibility — fail.** The 844×390 reduced-motion midpoint cuts off the bottom of the assembly and label 10 in the actual viewport. On desktop, non-current explanatory paragraphs remain visible at opacity 0.45; their contrast falls below 4.5:1. Names, text equivalent, focus indication, keyboard use and static reduced-motion state selection are present in the tested evidence. - **Repair/review burden — not assessed.** No repair is included in the material reviewed. Repair time, tokens, cost and human review time were not supplied and remain unknown. ## Gates | Gate | Result | Evidence and finding | |---|---|---| | C01 | pass | Source: complete doctype HTML with inline CSS and JavaScript; browser results record no network attempts. | | C02 | pass | Source and hero capture: identity, exact required concept disclaimer and editorial copy are present; no purchase claim found. | | C03 | pass | Source definitions, component guide and desktop midpoint capture show ten named and keyed components. | | C04 | pass | Source specifies rotations 305.25°, 63° and 180°, centered pivots and longer minute hand; assembled capture shows the three hands. | | C05 | pass | Source and desktop midpoint capture show transparent crystal, open bezel and case, coaxial separation, partial rotor and illustrative mechanical details. | | C06 | pass | `browser/results.json` reports midpoint difference, reassembly match and reverse states at the tested sizes; `browser/followup.json` confirms holds, ordinary wheel and Explore navigation. Source holds and interpolates both directions. | | C07 | pass | Browser checks report keyboard navigation, progress values and focus; source labels three buttons and exposes progress. Focus is visible in `320x568-reduce-keyboard-focus.png`. | | C08 | **fail** | `844x390-reduce-p50.png` visibly cuts off the rotor/caseback and label 10 below the viewport; reduced `.vp` has `min-height:520px` at a 390px viewport. Other supplied normal-motion phone and landscape midpoint captures fit; no horizontal overflow was reported. | | C09 | pass | Source removes smooth scrolling and scrub under reduced motion and switches static views. Browser tests report selection surviving wheel and resize; follow-up reports live preference change snaps to assembled and remains static. The separate C08 viewport failure still applies. | | C10 | **fail** | `browser/followup.json` records visible non-current `.cap` text at rgb(167,175,185), opacity 0.45. Even composited on pure black this yields only approximately 2.54:1, below 4.5:1; the actual near-black background does not rescue it. `1440x900-reduce-p50.png` shows these paragraphs. Landmarks, descriptive equivalent, labels and focus are otherwise evidenced. Axe's contrast result was incomplete, not a pass. | ## Evidence reconciliation The original results contain 191 observations with two failures: reduced-motion landscape labels visible and no runtime errors. The landscape screenshot confirms a real viewport clipping failure, even though the scene itself extends to 520px and some geometry checks are relative to that scene. The 96 console messages across eight contexts are malformed SVG line `x2` lengths in caseback screws: formatted coordinate strings are concatenated with `2.4` in `scr`, producing values such as `108.02.4`. These are nonfatal attribute errors and a small visual-detail defect, not evidence of a JavaScript crash; the displayed watch and controls still operate. The follow-up reports no new errors in its scoped checks, which does not erase the initial attribute errors. The final PNGs were captured after 400 ms for the author's original caption transition; earlier two-frame captures are retained separately by the operator. No source correction was made. Browser evidence is Chromium emulation only; no cross-browser or full accessibility certification is implied. Operator restrictions on source edits and browser use by this reviewer are review conditions, not candidate defects.