# WATCH-EXPLODE-01 evaluation freeze — 2026-10-24 Evaluation rubric v1.0. Frozen before results integration in this implementation. Frozen task v1.0 SHA-256: d9a590c1c356e32cbaa347145135f50914f27c5aea0f976ddcbc5bce31716d3c. Separate from the locked Toybox Clock 0/21 protocol. One sample cannot establish a universal winner. No combined score or default quality ranking. Every judgment is pass, fail, or not assessed, with evidence scope (source, browser, visual, human review), finding, and reference. Operational/privacy/budget blocks are not coding failures. Unknown measurements stay null. First and repaired acceptance are separate; repair never changes first acceptance. 1. Functional acceptance: C01 standalone complete HTML, C02 required identity/honest copy, C06 reversible progress 0 → .5 → 1 and reverse, C07 keyboard state controls and progress. A complete response is not acceptance. A known source defect can fail a check; a source-only review cannot pass runtime behavior. 2. Visual craftsmanship: composition, lighting/material cues, typography, coherent motion. Only assess actual authorized comparable views at the same viewport, theme and progress. Record a concrete strength and weakness. No ratings until render evidence exists. 3. Reference/anatomy fidelity: C03 ten distinguishable components, C04 10:10:30 (305.25°,63°,180° ±2°), common pivot and lengths, C05 transparent crystal, open rings, coaxial order, partial rear rotor, recognizable movement. This is conceptual anatomy, not physical movement simulation or engineering certification. A mechanically unverified illustration cannot win engineering accuracy. 4. Accessibility: C08 1440×900,390×844,320×568,844×390 at p=0,.5,1 and resize; C09 reduced-motion static state selection without smooth/continuous motion; C10 landmarks, names, focus, text equivalents and normal-text contrast ≥4.5:1. No overflow or overlapping essential labels. 5. Repair/review burden: one bounded continuation OR correction, disclosed cap, exact repair scope, additional request time/tokens/cost and human review time (unknown if not logged). No hidden rescue. Retain every original byte/hash and receipt. First-attempt acceptance requires all C01–C10 passes supported by appropriate evidence from the unaltered first response. Truncation is incomplete at stage 1 permanently. Repaired acceptance uses the separate artifact and the same C01–C10 gates; includes extra resources and original outcome. Any fail means not accepted; any unassessed required gate means unverified. Operational exclusions remain not assessed. Visual craft is reported separately even after functional failure. Protocol: preserve → source/network safety inspection → authorized render capture → same checks → independent review. A blocked render is untested, never zero. New integrations must record prompt hash, exact model/route/settings, conditions deviations, finish reason, original/repair artifact hashes, source/receipt provenance and actual stage-specific measurements. Subscription covered means no incremental API charge, not free compute. Do not infer unknown invoice costs or recovery status.